Disclaimer

Before you proceed

In accordance with the rules of the Bar Council of India, advocates are not permitted to advertise or solicit work through communication in the public domain. This website has been published only to provide general information about VGNC, and is not intended as advertising, solicitation or inducement of any kind.

By clicking "I Accept" and proceeding further, you acknowledge and confirm that:

← Back to Insights

Black Money Act · October 2026

The Black Money Law: the rigors are live with no time-barring provisions

The Black Money Act puts no time limit on the notice that starts an assessment. Through section 72(c), it can also tax a foreign asset acquired decades before the Act existed. Whether that is constitutional, and how far it reaches, has been argued in the Supreme Court and four High Courts. This piece sets out what each has held, where the law stands today, and the one distinction that still offers a defence for old years: foreign income versus foreign assets.

1. How the Act reaches old assets

The Black Money (Undisclosed Foreign Income and Assets) and Imposition of Tax Act, 2015 (“BM Act”) charges tax under section 3 only for assessment years from 2016-17. Section 1(3) as enacted fixed 1 April 2016 as the commencement date. Order No. S.O. 1790(E) advanced it to 1 July 2015, so that a one-time compliance window under section 59 could operate.

The 2015 window. Chapter VI (sections 59 to 72) let “any person” declare an undisclosed foreign asset acquired from income chargeable to tax for any year before AY 2016-17. Declarations were due by 30 September 2015, and tax and penalty by 31 December 2015 (Ministry of Finance press release, 1 July 2015). The price was 30% tax (section 60) plus a penalty of 100% of that tax (section 61): 60% in all. The declared asset was kept out of total income (section 64), and the declaration could not be used as evidence against the declarant (section 67). Section 71(d) shut the window to persons already under notice or whose information had already come from a foreign jurisdiction.

Section 72(c) then deals with those who stayed away:

  • where any asset has been acquired or made prior to commencement of this Act, and no declaration in respect of such asset is made under this Chapter, such asset shall be deemed to have been acquired or made in the year in which a notice under section 10 is issued by the Assessing Officer and the provisions of this Act shall apply accordingly.

Read with the proviso to section 3(1), which taxes an undisclosed foreign asset at its value in the year it comes to notice, an undeclared pre-2015 asset is pulled into the year of the section 10 notice and taxed at 30%, with a penalty of three times the tax under section 41.

Why the 2015 window matters constitutionally. The Revenue’s answer to the charge of retrospectivity rests on the window. The Act, it argues, gave everyone a chance to come clean at 60%. Section 72(c) impact those who chose not to. That argument works for persons who could have used the window. It is weaker for persons whom section 71(d) shut out, and weakest where the asset had ceased to exist before the Act began.

2. What the courts have held

No court has struck down the BM Act for retrospective operation. The Supreme Court has accepted its operation as a tax law from AY 2016-17, at least at the interim stage. The High Courts have divided on a narrower question: whether section 72(c) can reach assets and events that ended before the Act began.

Case Court and date Question Outcome
Union of India v. Gautam Khaitan, Crl. Appeal 1563/2019 Supreme Court (three judges), 15.10.2019 Was the Act made retrospective by advancing commencement to 1.7.2015? No; Delhi HC’s interim restraint on prosecution set aside
Shrivardhan Mohta v. Union of India, (2019) 102 taxmann.com 273 Calcutta High Court, 2019 Should the Act apply only prospectively from 1.4.2016? Writ dismissed
Anila Rasiklal Mehta v. Union of India, NM 283/2019 in WP 1300/2018 Bombay High Court (Division Bench), 13.03.2020 Can section 72(c) apply to persons barred from section 59 by section 71(d)? Prima facie arguable; proceedings continue, no coercive measures
Dhanashree Ravindra Pandit v. Income Tax Department, Crl. P. 101368/2019 Karnataka High Court, 07.06.2024 Can prosecution rest on foreign accounts closed in 2010? Prosecution under ss. 50 and 52 quashed under Article 20
Income Tax Department v. Dhanashree Ravindra Pandit, SLP (Crl) 11016/2024, now Crl. Appeal 3557/2024 Supreme Court (Abhay S. Oka and Augustine George Masih, JJ.), 23.08.2024 Does the Article 20 reasoning stand? Leave granted; High Court’s para 15 stayed; appeal pending

Union of India v. Gautam Khaitan (Supreme Court, 2019). The Delhi High Court had restrained prosecution under sections 50 and 51, holding that the Act was given retrospective effect from 1 July 2015. The Supreme Court disagreed. Tax is charged only for assessment years from 1 April 2016, on the asset’s value in the year it comes to notice. Commencement was advanced only so that the section 59 window could open: “The power has been exercised only in order to remove difficulties.” The penal provisions affect only a person who did not use section 59. Two limits matter. The appeal was against an interim order, and the Court said its observations were only for that purpose. The assessment year in that case was 2019-20.

Shrivardhan Mohta v. Union of India (Calcutta High Court, 2019). The Court dismissed a writ seeking a declaration that the Act applies only prospectively from 1 April 2016, and quashing of notices issued under it. The Revenue has relied on it in later cases.

Anila Rasiklal Mehta v. Union of India (Bombay High Court, 2020). Information on the petitioners’ foreign accounts had come from Singapore and the British Virgin Islands under section 90 arrangements, which brought them within section 71(d)(iii) and shut them out of the 2015 window. Section 10 notices then sought to tax, for AY 2017-18, assets linked to AYs 2008-09 and 2009-10. The Court noted that section 72(c) may give the Act retrospective operation, calling it “a highly debatable issue” given the penalty and prosecution provisions. It distinguished Gautam Khaitan because the section 59 bar was not in issue there. Bearing in mind the presumption of constitutionality, it let the proceedings continue but directed no coercive measures, and listed the writ for early hearing. Final disposal is awaited.

Dhanashree Ravindra Pandit v. Income Tax Department (Karnataka High Court, 2024). Two BVI companies of the petitioners held a UBS Singapore account, closed on 27 May 2010. In 2018 a section 10 notice issued for AY 2019-20, followed by prosecution under sections 50 and 52. The Court held that nothing existed when the Act came into force. A deeming fiction in section 72(c) cannot create criminal liability for facts that ended five years before the Act; prosecution on that basis fails Article 20(1). In its words, “Constitution of India is not a statute”; the Act’s rigour must pass muster of Article 20. The prosecution was quashed.

Dhanashree in the Supreme Court (2024, pending). The Revenue challenged the judgment in SLP (Crl) No. 11016/2024. On 23 August 2024 a Bench of Abhay S. Oka and Augustine George Masih, JJ. granted leave, and the matter is now Criminal Appeal No. 3557/2024. The Court recorded that the criminal petition had raised no challenge to the validity of section 72(c). It issued notice on the prayer for interim relief, reproduced paragraph 15 of the High Court’s judgment, the passage containing the Article 20 reasoning, and directed that this part of the judgment will remain stayed.

The stay is confined to paragraph 15. The order does not, in terms, stay the quashing of the prosecution. But the reasoning that carried the result is now under stay and cannot safely be cited as settled. Connected Revenue matters, including SLP (Crl) No. 15976/2024 (notice issued on 14 November 2024), have been tagged with the appeal. No final judgment has been reported.

The Supreme Court’s note that section 72(c) was never challenged matters in practice. A taxpayer who intends to rely on Article 20 against a prosecution resting on section 72(c) should plead the constitutional challenge expressly, and not seek quashing alone.

3. Old foreign income is not old foreign assets

Section 72(c) and the proviso to section 3(1) move only an asset into a later year. No provision does the same for income. Section 3(1) charges only from AY 2016-17, so foreign income of an earlier year that never became a foreign asset has no year in which the BM Act can charge it.

  • PCIT v. Income Tax Settlement Commission, (2019) 420 ITR 149 (Guj). For AYs 2004-05 to 2015-16, the High Court held that undisclosed foreign income for years before AY 2016-17 remains chargeable under the Income-tax Act, 1961, and upheld the Settlement Commission’s jurisdiction. It also held that not declaring under section 59 is not, by itself, a default. The Revenue’s writ was dismissed.
  • Vikas Marda (ITAT Kolkata), TS-956-ITAT-2024(Kol). BM Act proceedings for AYs 2014-15 and 2015-16 were quashed: the first assessment year under the Act is 2016-17, so the Assessing Officer could neither assess income nor levy penalty under sections 41 and 43 for earlier years.
  • Elangovan Malarmangai v. ACIT (ITAT Chennai), TS-508-ITAT-2025. The Tribunal observed that undisclosed foreign income is taxable under the BM Act only from AY 2016-17, while foreign assets are taxable regardless of when acquired. The case concerned assets and was decided on a wrong-AY notice, so the observation on income supports the reading but is not the ground of decision.

Two cautions keep this defence honest. First, income that was ever held abroad, even as a bank balance, can be recast as an asset, and section 72(c) is read by the Revenue as applying whatever the asset’s later disposal. For years up to AY 2015-16, section 149, as amended by the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2024, and its proviso will bar a fresh notice.

4. Where this leaves the law

  • As a tax, the Act runs from AY 2016-17 and taxes an old undisclosed asset at its value in the year of notice. The Supreme Court in Gautam Khaitan and the Calcutta High Court support that reading.
  • As a basis for prosecution for assets or conduct that ended before 1 July 2015, the Karnataka High Court in Dhanashree held that section 72(c) cannot be used, under Article 20(1). The Supreme Court has granted leave and stayed that reasoning; the point is open.
  • For persons barred from section 59 by section 71(d), the Bombay High Court has found the challenge arguable; the final outcome is not reported.
  • For old foreign income that never became an asset, the BM Act has no chargeable year, and the question becomes limitation under the Income-tax Act.

For anyone now holding an undeclared foreign asset, this history explains why the 2026 disclosure scheme is worth a serious look: the courts have not closed the door section 72(c) opens for tax. Our companion piece on FAST-DS 2026 explains who should use it before 31 December 2026.

This article is for general information and is not legal or tax advice. The Supreme Court appeal in Dhanashree and the Bombay High Court writ in Anila Rasiklal Mehta are pending; check their status before relying on this piece. Each case turns on its own facts.

← Back to Insights