A buyer who acquires an asset in an IBC liquidation sale does not take on the corporate debtor’s past dues. If an authority forces payment anyway, the NCLT can order it refunded. That is the core of a recent order of the NCLT, Allahabad Bench, dated 2 September 2026, in the liquidation of L.M.L. Limited.
The buyer, Positron Biogenics Private Limited, bought industrial land in Kanpur at a liquidation auction for Rs. 26.73 crore. The land was leasehold, held from the Uttar Pradesh State Industrial Development Authority (UPSIDA). When the buyer asked UPSIDA to transfer the lease, UPSIDA refused unless the buyer first paid about Rs. 82.53 lakh of the old company’s arrears from 2000 to 2009.
Every prospective buyer of a liquidation asset asks the same question: am I buying the asset, or the asset plus its history? This order answers this Question that past dues does’t come with asset.
The case: Positron Biogenics v. UPSIDA
The NCLT directed UPSIDA to refund the full amount to the auction purchaser. UPSIDA dues were left to be dealt with by Liquidator in terms of waterfall mechanism u/s 53 of the IBC. The order was passed in IA No. 485 of 2023 in CP (IB) No. 55/ALD/2017.
The sequence of events:
- M.L. Limited went into CIRP on 30 May 2017 and into liquidation on 23 March 2018.
- UPSIDA filed a claim of Rs. 2.77 crore in the insolvency process. It was admitted in full as an operational creditor claim.
- The liquidator auctioned Parcels A, B and C, Site-III, Panki Industrial Area, Kanpur on 4 October 2022. The sale was on an “as is where is, as is what is, whatever there is and without recourse” basis.
- The sale certificate was issued on 28 December 2022, and possession was handed over two days later.
- UPSIDA then demanded Rs. 82.53 lakh as a condition for transferring the lease. This was Rs. 18.86 lakh of maintenance charges for 2000–2009 plus Rs. 63.31 lakh of interest on them, with small amounts of lease rent and GST.
- The buyer’s pharmaceutical project was stalled. It wrote to UPSIDA disputing the liability and asked UPSIDA to claim it from the liquidator. It then paid the amount by demand draft on 25 August 2023, expressly under protest and reserving its right to approach the NCLT.
- UPSIDA issued the transfer memorandum only after the buyer signed an affidavit and indemnity bond undertaking to pay its demands.
The NCLT held that the payment was made under compulsion and was not an acceptance of liability. The affidavit and indemnity were treated as part of the same protest payment, not as an independent undertaking.
Why the buyer does not inherit the dues
- Pre-sale dues belong in the Section 53 waterfall. UPSIDA had already lodged its claim in the insolvency process, and it had been admitted. A creditor cannot have its claim collated against the estate and also recover the same dues from the buyer as the price of transferring the lease. The Tribunal relied on the NCLAT’s decision in Bhatpara Municipality v. Nicco Eastern Pvt. Ltd. (Company Appeal (AT) (Ins) No. 714 of 2021). That case held that property tax dues from auction purchaser before the sale are akin to an unsecured creditor’s claim and must be paid and dealt with by the Liquidator, under Section 53. The NCLAT in turn followed the Supreme Court in AI Champdany Industries Ltd. v. Official Liquidator.
- The seller pays dues accrued up to the date of sale. Bhatpara draws on Section 55(1)(g) of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. That provision makes the seller liable for public charges and rent accrued up to the sale. In a liquidation sale, the seller is the corporate debtor acting through the liquidator, and its liability is met from the liquidation estate.
- “As is where is” puts the buyer on notice; it does not make the buyer a debtor. The auction document asked bidders to make their own inquiries about dues affecting the asset. The NCLT held that this is not the same as an undertaking to pay the corporate debtor’s debts over and above the bid price. Nothing in the process document or the sale certificate said the buyer would assume UPSIDA’s dues. What passed to the buyer was the leasehold interest, not the corporate debtor’s liabilities.
- Interest does not change the character of the debt. UPSIDA calculated interest up to August 2023, well after the auction. The Tribunal held that interest on a 2000–2009 default is still a pre-CIRP liability, however late it is computed. Fresh obligations under the new lease deed of 6 November 2023 bind the buyer, only for its own tenure.
What are the judicial precedents from the Supreme Court, High Courts, NCLAT and NCLT have held
The Positron order applies a principle that has been upheld at every level of the judiciary, for every common kind of past due. Since 2009 the Supreme Court has held that a buyer from a liquidator does not pay the company’s old municipal or electricity dues. Under the IBC, the NCLAT has applied this to property tax, industrial development authority dues and electricity arrears, including where the sale was on an “as is where is” basis.
| Case | Forum and year | Dues in dispute | What was held |
| AI Champdany Industries Ltd. v. Official Liquidator, (2009) 4 SCC 486 | Supreme Court, 2009 | Municipal property tax | Municipal tax is not a charge on the property; the municipality must queue before the liquidator, and the buyer is not liable. |
| NESCO v. Raghunath Paper Mills (P) Ltd., (2012) 13 SCC 479 | Supreme Court, 2012 | Electricity arrears | Buyer at an “as is where is, whatever there is” liquidation sale held not liable for arrears. |
| Paschimanchal Vidyut Vitran Nigam v. Raman Ispat, 2023 INSC 625 | Supreme Court, 2023 | Electricity dues | IBC overrides the Electricity Act; the discom must recover through the liquidation process under Section 53. |
| Tata Power Western Odisha v. Jagannath Sponge, CA 5556 of 2023 | Supreme Court, 2023 | Electricity arrears | Arrears cannot be a condition for a new connection; that would negate the clean slate. Applied by the NCLAT to liquidation buyers. |
| Mamta Binani v. Kolkata Municipal Corporation, WPO 2435 of 2022 | Calcutta High Court, 2026 | Property tax | “As is where is” clauses cannot revive municipal claims; tax runs only from the buyer’s date of title. |
| Alpesh Gems v. Surat Municipal Corporation, Special Civil Application No. 4905 of 2022 | Gujarat High Court, 2022 | Property tax | Pre-sale tax to be claimed from the liquidator; buyer liable only from the date of purchase. |
| Bhatpara Municipality v. Nicco Eastern, CA(AT)(Ins) 714 of 2021 | NCLAT | Property tax | Pre-sale dues are an unsecured creditor’s claim under Section 53; buyer not liable. |
| Shiv Shakti Inter Globe Exports v. KTC Foods, CA(AT)(Ins) 650 of 2020 | NCLAT, 2022 | Electricity and contingent liabilities | Going-concern buyer takes the company free of past and contingent liabilities. |
| Eastern Power Distribution Co. of AP v. Maithan Alloys, CA(AT)(Ins) 961 of 2021 | NCLAT, 2022 | Electricity, pre-CIRP and CIRP period | Pre-CIRP dues go to Section 53, CIRP-period dues are insolvency costs; regulations putting them on the buyer conflict with the IBC. |
| HSIIDC v. Aar Aar Technoplast, CA (AT) (Ins) No. 606 of 2021 | NCLAT, 2022 | Industrial development authority dues | After the sale certificate and possession, pre-auction dues claimed as an operational creditor cannot be raised against the buyer. |
| Chinar Steel Segments Centre v. Samir Kumar Agarwal, CA (AT) (Ins) No. 1355 of 2022 | NCLAT, 2023 | Electricity arrears | Discom cannot insist that the buyer pay the company’s arrears before acting on the connection. |
| Paschimanchal Vidyut Vitran Nigam v. HSA Traders, CA(AT)(Ins) 527 of 2023 | NCLAT, 2024 | Electricity, Rs. 39.16 lakh | New connection ordered without arrears, despite an “as is where is” sale. |
| UPCL v. Shyam Baba Developers & Builders, CA(AT)(Ins) 346 of 2023 | NCLAT, 2025 | Electricity, Rs. 7.67 crore admitted claim | Connection restored without pre-CIRP dues; the discom must take its share under Section 53. |
| Positron Biogenics v. UPSIDA, IA 485 of 2023 | NCLT Allahabad, 2026 | Industrial authority lease arrears | Rs. 82.53 lakh paid under protest ordered to be refunded. |
| Harish Kumar Agarwal v. PSPCL, IA(IBC)/1013(CH)/2026 | NCLT Chandigarh, 2026 | Electricity, about Rs. 1.61 crore with interest | A claim left unpaid for want of funds in the waterfall does not shift to the buyer. |
Two threads run through these decisions. The creditor’s remedy is the claim against the liquidation estate, whether or not that claim is ultimately paid. And a general “as is where is” clause puts the buyer on notice; it does not make the buyer pay the company’s debts.
A clean slate in liquidation: what it means and where it comes from
The phrase “clean slate” comes from the Supreme Court’s decision in Ghanashyam Mishra & Sons v. Edelweiss ARC (2021). That case concerned resolution plans. Once a plan is approved under Section 31, it binds everyone, and claims not in the plan are extinguished.
Although the Liquidation has no protection of Section 31, the buyer’s protection is built from other provisions and from case law:
- Section 53 channels every creditor’s claim into one waterfall paid from the sale proceeds. The creditor’s remedy is against the liquidation estate, not against the asset or its buyer.
- Section 238 gives the Code overriding effect over inconsistent laws, including the rules of development authorities.
- Section 32A protects the buyer of a liquidation asset from attachment or confiscation for offences the corporate debtor committed before CIRP. This includes action by investigating agencies such as the Enforcement Directorate.
- Section 60(5) lets the buyer bring an authority’s demand before the NCLT itself, as Positron did.
The dues are not “settled” in the sense of being paid in full. UPSIDA keeps its admitted claim and ranks as an operational creditor under Section 53(1)(f), so it may or may not recover in terms of sec.53 of IBC. The point is that the buyer is not the one who pays.
Liquidation sale vs SARFAESI auction
A SARFAESI buyer acquires one secured creditor’s enforcement, while a liquidation buyer acquires the result of a collective process covering every creditor. That structural difference is why a liquidation title is usually cleaner.
Under SARFAESI, the bank sells to recover its own debt. The borrower can still challenge the measures before the DRT under Section 17, and the dispute often continues after the sale certificate is issued. Other creditors, statutory authorities and lessors are not bound by the bank’s sale, so the buyer may still face their claims.
| Point | IBC liquidation sale | SARFAESI auction |
| Who sells | Liquidator, for all stakeholders | One secured creditor, for its own dues |
| Other creditors’ claims | Collected and paid through the Section 53 waterfall | Not bound by the sale; may pursue the asset or the buyer |
| Old dues of authorities and lessors | Payable from the liquidation estate u/s 53 and not from buyer | Often demanded from the buyer under “as is where is” terms |
| Borrower’s challenge | Corporate debtor is under the liquidator’s control | Section 17 application before DRT; can continue after sale |
| Attachment for the old owner’s offences | Protected by Section 32A | No equivalent expressed statutory protection |
| Forum for disputes | Single forum: NCLT under Section 60(5) | DRT, civil courts, authorities and writ courts |
The SARFAESI buyer’s position has improved, which a fair comparison must note. Section 13(8), amended in 2016, ends the borrower’s right to redeem once the auction notice is published. The Supreme Court applied this strictly in Celir LLP v. Bafna Motors, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1209
Liquidation sales can also be challenged, by promoters, rival bidders or creditors. Still, the buyer’s legal footing is stronger. The liquidation process is designed to settle every creditor’s claim against the liquidation estate, not just one creditor’s claim against one asset.
What a prospective buyer should do
The law is on the liquidation buyer’s side, but enforcing it took Positron about three years and Rs. 82.53 lakh of blocked money. Price that cost into the bid.
Before bidding:
- Check the claims list on the IBBI website for any authority, lessor or utility connected with the asset, and the admitted amount. An admitted claim is the buyer’s strongest shield.
- Read the asset memorandum and the process document for any clause that makes the buyer bear past dues. A specific assumption clause is very different from a general “as is where is” clause.
- For leasehold land, find out the authority’s transfer conditions, transfer fees and timelines. Fees for transferring the lease to the new owner are a separate question from the old company’s arrears.
After the sale:
- If an authority demands past dues, first ask it in writing to claim from the liquidator.
- If you must pay to keep the project moving, pay expressly under protest and record that you will approach the NCLT. Positron was diligent and its letters said exactly this.
- If an indemnity or affidavit is demanded, state in it that it is given under protest and without accepting liability.
- File promptly under Section 60(5). Delay weakens the argument that the payment was made under compulsion.
Conclusion
A liquidation buyer buys the asset, not the corporate debtor’s history. Authorities with old dues must claim from the liquidation estate under Section 53, and the NCLT will order a refund if they extract payment from the buyer. For investors comparing liquidation and SARFAESI opportunities, this collective clean-up of claims is the main reason a liquidation title usually stands on better legal footing.
The protection is real, but it has to be asserted. A buyer who documents its protest and moves the NCLT promptly will usually get its money back. A buyer who pays quietly may find it has paid the corporate debtor’s debts for it.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice. The NCLT order discussed is a decision of one bench and may be challenged on appeal. Consult counsel on the specific asset before bidding.