Disclaimer

Before you proceed

In accordance with the rules of the Bar Council of India, advocates are not permitted to advertise or solicit work through communication in the public domain. This website has been published only to provide general information about VGNC, and is not intended as advertising, solicitation or inducement of any kind.

By clicking "I Accept" and proceeding further, you acknowledge and confirm that:

← Back to Insights

PMLA · October 2026

Property acquired even before the alleged offence can be attached under PMLA — but only if the property directly acquired out of proceeds of crime is not traceable

Yes — a property bought years before the alleged offence can be attached under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (PMLA), but only as property of equivalent value, and only when the actual tainted proceeds cannot be traced. A Division Bench of the Chhattisgarh High Court held so in a reported judgment on 22 April 2026 in Tushar Sahu & Ors. v. Deputy Director, ED (MA No. 21 of 2026, AFR). The Appellate Tribunal under SAFEMA, New Delhi, reached the same conclusion on 4 August 2026 in Noohu Khan & Ors. v. Deputy Director, Directorate of Enforcement, Cochin (FPA-PMLA-6839 to 6841/COCHIN/2023), delivered by the Chairman, Justice Munishwar Nath Bhandari.

The Tribunal’s ruling matters because the Kerala High Court — whose territory that case arose from — has taken the opposite view. Anyone facing attachment of a pre-offence asset now has to understand both lines of authority, and the conditions the courts have attached to the power.

The facts

Kerala SIDCO awarded M/s Som Projects Pvt. Ltd. a land-development contract for the Telecom City Project at Menamkulam: excavate 1,29,209 m³ of sand and refill with 30% red earth, for Rs. 11.31 crore. Clause 13 barred sub-contracting without SIDCO’s written consent. Som Projects sub-contracted the whole work anyway, to M/s KGN Civil Construction (Mohammed Sadique Hussain) and M/s Veeyem Group Engineers (Noohu Khan).

Between September 2010 and December 2011, the prosecution case is that the sub-contractors over-excavated 20,364.76 m³ within the site, removed another 19,181 m³ from adjoining government puramboke land without a quarrying permit, and refilled only 11.82% red earth. Two SIDCO officers allegedly took Rs. 1.29 crore and Rs. 6 lakh in cash to look away. The Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau charge-sheeted the accused under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and Section 120-B IPC; the ED recorded an ECIR.

The ED quantified proceeds of crime as follows:

Head Amount (Rs.)
Illegal excavation of 39,545.7 m³ sand at Rs. 875/m³ 3,46,02,488
Sub-contractors’ profit from the unauthorised sub-contracts 1,57,60,335
Cash received by the MD of Kerala SIDCO 1,29,48,800
Som Projects’ profit from unauthorised sub-contracting 40,73,260
Cash received by the AGM of Kerala SIDCO 6,00,000
Total 6,79,84,883

 

Provisional Attachment Order No. 01/2023 dated 31 March 2023 attached properties worth Rs. 5.24 crore — including properties worth Rs. 1.28 crore of Mohammed Sadique Hussain and Rs. 1.61 crore of Noohu Khan. The Adjudicating Authority confirmed it on 15 September 2023.

The appellants’ argument

The appellants ran a single point. They did not contest the allegations on merits. Their case was that all 55 attached properties were bought before the crime period, for modest sums, and so could not be “proceeds of crime”. The impugned order itself described them as attached for “equivalent value”, not as direct or indirect proceeds.

They relied on:

  • Satish Motilal Bidri v. Union of India, Kerala High Court, WP(Crl) 406/2024, 28 June 2024, and Davy Varghese v. Deputy Director, ED, Kerala High Court, WP(Crl) 1354/2023, 16 December 2024 — holding that property acquired before the commission of the crime cannot be provisionally attached as proceeds of crime.
  • Seema Garg v. Deputy Director, ED, Punjab & Haryana High Court (2020).
  • Pavana Dibbur v. Directorate of Enforcement, Supreme Court (2023).
  • Vijay Madanlal Choudhary v. Union of India, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 929 — for the proposition that only proceeds of crime, and not any other property, can be attached.

How the Tribunal read Section 2(1)(u)

The Tribunal held that the definition of “proceeds of crime” has three limbs, each separated by “or”, and none can be read as surplus. Section 2(1)(u) defines proceeds of crime as any property derived or obtained, directly or indirectly, as a result of criminal activity relating to a scheduled offence, or the value of any such property, or, where such property is taken or held outside the country, property equivalent in value held within the country or abroad.

Limb What it covers Nature of property
1. Property derived or obtained, directly or indirectly The bribe, the sale proceeds, and anything bought with them Tainted
2. “The value of any such property” Any other property of the accused, when the tainted property is not traceable Untainted, attached for equivalent value
3. Property equivalent in value, where proceeds are taken or held abroad Property in India or abroad, when the proceeds have gone outside India Untainted, attached for equivalent value

 

The second limb carried the case. The Tribunal relied on paragraph 68 of the three-judge bench judgment in Vijay Madanlal Choudhary, where the Supreme Court rejected the argument that equivalent-value attachment is available only when proceeds are held outside India, calling it tenuous. The Court said the definition is wide enough to cover not only property derived from criminal activity but also the value of such property.

The Tribunal also adopted:

  • Deputy Director, ED v. Axis Bank, Delhi High Court (2019) — which divided attachable property into “tainted” property and “deemed tainted” or “alternative attachable” property.
  • Prakash Industries Ltd. v. ED, 2022 SCC OnLine Del 2087 — which expressly disagreed with Seema Garg and held that reading the definition otherwise would erase the words “value of any such property”.
  • Dilbag Singh v. Union of India, Punjab & Haryana High Court (Division Bench), 13 November 2024 — where the same High Court that decided Seema Garg held it no longer good law in light of Vijay Madanlal Choudhary.
  • Its own earlier orders in Sadananda Nayak v. Deputy Director, ED (14 October 2024) and Besco International FZE v. Deputy Director, ED (31 July 2024).

On reliance placed on Pavana Dibbur, the Tribunal rejected the argument and accepted Dilbag Singh’s reading: that case concerned property attached as direct or indirect proceeds, and the Supreme Court was not asked to interpret the second limb. On the Kerala High Court judgments, the Tribunal said paragraph 68 of Vijay Madanlal Choudhary was not placed before that Court, and that paragraph 298 — which the Kerala High Court relied on — only says that what can be attached is proceeds of crime, without defining the term.

The Tribunal’s reasoning is clear: if pre-offence property were immune, an accused could commit the offence, siphon the proceeds immediately, and leave nothing to attach till the trial ends.

The limits on attaching other property as “equivalent value”

The ruling is not a licence to attach any asset of any accused. The Tribunal, and the High Court decisions it adopted, built in four conditions.

  1. Untraceability is a condition precedent. The second limb applies only when the property derived from the offence is not available — siphoned, vanished, suppressed or concealed. If the tainted asset can be found, that is what must be attached.
  2. Equivalence in value. Untainted property can be attached only up to the value of the illicit gain. Axis Bank requires at least a tentative assessment of the wrongful gain before attachment is confirmed, and confiscation must be restricted to that value.
  3. The accused must have held an interest in the property during the criminal activity. Prakash Industries, quoting Axis Bank, holds that it must be shown that the person accused of money laundering had an interest in the property at least till the time of the proscribed activity.
  4. Bona fide third-party rights are protected. Rights acquired for valid consideration by third parties before the predicate offence stand saved.

Where the law stands

The weight of recent authority favours attachment of pre-offence property as equivalent value, but the Supreme Court has not settled the point directly. Kerala remains the clearest contrary jurisdiction.

Forum Decision View on pre-offence property
SAFEMA Appellate Tribunal Noohu Khan, 4 Aug 2026 Attachable as equivalent value if proceeds untraceable
Chhattisgarh HC (Division Bench) Tushar Sahu & Ors. v. Deputy Director, ED, MA No. 21 of 2026, 2026:CGHC:18260-DB (AFR), 22 Apr 2026 Attachable as equivalent value, even if lawfully acquired before the offence, including family members’ property; Section 42 appeals dismissed
Delhi HC (Division Bench) Arun Suri v. ED, 2026 SCC OnLine Del 673, 16 Feb 2026 Even ancestral property held since 1991 attachable as equivalent value
Kerala HC Davy Varghese, 16 Dec 2024; Satish Motilal Bidri, 28 Jun 2024 Not attachable
Punjab & Haryana HC (Division Bench) Dilbag Singh, 13 Nov 2024 Attachable; Seema Garg no longer good law
Delhi HC Prakash Industries, 2022; Axis Bank, 2019 Attachable as “deemed tainted” property, with safeguards

 

Three points remain open.

  • The Kerala conflict. An appeal from the Tribunal lies to the High Court under Section 42 PMLA. In a Kochi-zone matter, that High Court is Kerala’s, which has taken the opposite view twice. The Tribunal’s answer — that paragraph 68 of Vijay Madanlal Choudhary was not cited there — will be tested before the very Court whose judgments it declined to apply.
  • Pavana Dibbur. The Tribunal treats it as confined to direct proceeds. Defence counsel will continue to argue that its reasoning bars attachment of property with no link to the crime.
  • The Axis Bank SLP. As Prakash Industries recorded, an SLP against Axis Bank is pending before the Supreme Court with a status-quo order, though the judgment has not been stayed. A ruling there could resolve the question either way.

The High Court view: Tushar Sahu v. Deputy Director, ED

Apart from the above Tribunal’s order, there is another reported High Court judgment that preceded it. On 22 April 2026, a Division Bench of the Chhattisgarh High Court (Ramesh Sinha CJ and Ravindra Kumar Agrawal J) dismissed nine statutory appeals under Section 42 PMLA in Tushar Sahu & Ors. v. Deputy Director, Directorate of Enforcement, MA No. 21 of 2026 and connected appeals, 2026:CGHC:18260-DB (AFR).

The facts. The case arose from the Chhattisgarh coal-levy ECIR. The ED alleged that a syndicate collected an illegal levy of Rs. 25 per tonne after a government order dated 15 July 2020, and that former IAS officer Ranu Sahu received Rs. 5.52 crore of proceeds while posted as Collector. The ED attached properties of her and her family members in two blocks: those bought after 15 July 2020 as direct proceeds, and those bought before it — some as early as 2018 — as “value thereof”. The AA confirmed the attachment on 9 October 2023, and the Appellate Tribunal upheld it on 16 October 2025.

The argument. The appellants said the ED had mechanically split the properties by purchase date, that Ranu Sahu’s alleged role began only in June 2021, and that properties bought before 15 July 2020 could not be proceeds of crime.

The holding. The Court rejected this, relying on paragraph 68 of Vijay Madanlal Choudhary and the Tribunal’s reasoning in Sadananda Nayak. It held that the value limb applies irrespective of whether the substitute property was acquired lawfully or before the offence. It set out a two-part test (para 71): property bought before the offence period may be attached if

  1. the existence of proceeds of crime is established, and
  2. their equivalent value cannot otherwise be recovered from the directly tainted assets.

Three further points in the judgment matter in practice.

  • Family members are within reach. The Court said the authorities may proceed against any other property of the accused “or related persons, including family members”, to the extent of the proceeds. That goes further than Axis Bank, which required the accused to hold an interest in the property. Expect this to be contested.
  • The burden falls on the holder. The Court would not “do the arithmetic” of every rupee. It asked whether the appellants gave a plausible explanation of their funding, and upheld findings that claimed agricultural income was unproven because the family did not hold enough land in the relevant years. The Section 24 presumption stood unrebutted.
  • Single-member Adjudicating Authority. The Court held a single-member bench, even a non-judicial one, competent to adjudicate (para 56).

Noohu Khan was decided three months later and does not cite Tushar Sahu. The two reach the same result by the same route.

What this means if property is attached by ED under PMLA

The appellants in Noohu Khan lost largely because they ran one argument — date of acquisition — and nothing else. “I bought it before the offence” is no longer enough on its own outside Kerala. A stronger challenge to equivalent-value attachment examines each condition the law itself imposes.

  1. Make the ED prove untraceability. Ask whether the PAO records why the tainted proceeds could not be traced. Tushar Sahu makes this the second limb of its test; an order that jumps to equivalent value without that finding is vulnerable.
  2. Make the ED prove the proceeds themselves. The first limb of the Tushar Sahu test is that the existence of proceeds of crime is established. Attack the quantum and the evidence for it — in that case, diary entries — before arguing about which property answers for it.
  3. Test the quantification. Equivalent value is capped at the illicit gain. Challenge the rate, the quantity and any double counting — in Noohu Khan, for example, sand-sale gains and sub-contract profits were computed as separate heads.
  4. Check whose gain it was. Equivalent-value property should answer for the gain attributable to that person. Tushar Sahu extends the reach to family members’ property; where the holder had no link to the accused’s gain, argue the Axis Bank requirement that the accused held an interest in the property.
  5. Prove legitimate funding with documents, not assertions. In Tushar Sahu, claimed agricultural income failed because land records showed the family did not hold enough land to earn it. Land, crop, bank and tax records must line up year by year.
  6. Do not rely on income-tax orders alone. A CIT(A) or ITAT order accepting the source of funds helps, but it is no shield by itself. Tax proceedings ask whether an investment is explained, not whether it is criminal in origin.
  7. Keep explanations consistent with your Section 50 statements. Inconsistency turns a documentary defence into a disputed question of fact.
  8. Protect third parties early. Banks, buyers and others holding bona fide rights acquired for value before the offence should assert them before the Adjudicating Authority, with documents.
  9. Contest the merits where you can. The Tribunal in Noohu Khan repeatedly noted that the appellants did not dispute their involvement. Silence on merits was read against them.
  10. Win it before the Adjudicating Authority. A writ against a PAO succeeds only where the order is wholly without jurisdiction or there is no material at all, and a Section 42 appeal lies only on a question of law — Tushar Sahu found none. The factual record built under Section 8 is usually decisive.

Attachment is provisional. Confiscation follows only on conviction under Section 8(5), or under Section 8(7) where trial cannot proceed. The fight over valuation and traceability is worth having at the attachment stage, because it shapes what is finally at risk.

Disclaimer

This article is for general information and is not legal advice. It reflects the law as understood on the date above. Readers facing attachment under PMLA should seek advice on the facts of their own case.

Sources

  • Tushar Sahu & Ors. v. Deputy Director, Directorate of Enforcement, MA No. 21 of 2026 and connected appeals, 2026:CGHC:18260-DB, Chhattisgarh High Court (Division Bench), judgment dated 22 April 2026 (AFR)
  • Noohu Khan & Ors. v. Deputy Director, ED, Cochin, FPA-PMLA-6839–6841/COCHIN/2023, Appellate Tribunal under SAFEMA, order dated 4 August 2026

Arun Suri v. Enforcement Directorate, 2026 SCC OnLine Del 673 — SCC Times report

← Back to Insights